A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS BETWEEN BROOKLYN 99 AND DEFENDERS AND RIDERS OF BERK
Brooklyn Nine-Nine and the Riders/Defenders of Berk have more in common than differences.
First we have to note that the target audience is different. Brooklyn Nine-Nine target more mature audiences while Riders/Defenders target the kids. The way I watched them was different as well. Brooklyn Nine-Nine had me in so deep that I finished 5 seasons with 22 episodes in 2 days, so what is sleep? Was it worth it? Yes. Should I have done it? No. Riders/Defenders on the other hand was something new to me as it felt like I binged watched it, I guess you could say that it’s binging in moderation. To be honest, watching TV and analyzing every possible detail is a weird thing, at first you need to have a conscious effort while doing this, and then suddenly it comes naturally to you.
In terms of narrative, they both have a main character who is bubbly and wants the best for his team in Jake Peralta and Hiccup. The love interest which will be developed over time in Amy Santiago and Astrid. A head of the area in Captain Raymond Holt and Stoick. They have day-to-day problems and enemies that they want to overcome.
I first fell in love with the HTTYD Franchise when the movie went out. Ever since, I always waited for the next film even to the point of reading the novels, which to my surprise, was very different from the movies. The first movie left me awestruck, wanting to know more about life on Berk, I was able to see a few episodes of the series, but I never got hooked, I guess what I wanted was something else back then, but this time, I appreciated the lessons that Season One has taught me.
Brooklyn Nine-Nine was something else, I fell in love with a cold-open which was a different way to start a show. In particular it was the one where Jake Peralta sings “I want it that way” by the backstreet boys. Watching all 5 seasons, this specific cold-open didn’t happen ‘til Season 5 in the middle of the season. I guess seeing this cold-open was what motivated me to binge watch Nine-Nine. To find out which episode did this and what the content of the entire episode was. The search was fun and it was worth it.
Riders/Defenders on the other hand, I only started to love it towards the end of Season One and the start of Season Two. It was really hard to watch during the first season as the animation styles were different, but the story, comedic relief and plot developments made up for it. Season Two was amazing as the animation style changed to look more like the movie which fixed my initial problem, aside from that, Season Two also had multiple problems coming their way such as Dagur, the Screaming Death and Alvin the Treacherous.
The comedic relief provided by Brooklyn Nine-Nine and Riders/Defenders was fairly similar. It’s usually the characters which you know are stupid and have their moments of glory, like Ruffnut and Tuffnut, while in Brooklyn Nine-Nine we have the obsessed best friend of Jake Peralta, Charles Boyle. Ruffnut and Tuffnut have always had minor rolls in Riders/Defenders and on occasion some biggers ones. Likewise, the same happens with Boyle, in which there is rarely an episode that features him. Although, when they are shown we can see that they do what they can to help or in Ruffnut and Tuffnut’s case, get it over with.
Here’s the part that is really interesting for me. I see both of them being sit-coms, but I only have a problem with Riders/Defenders about continuity. Brooklyn Nine-Nine being a police precinct and all has a lot of crime coming and out, which makes it difficult to have an episode on continuity unless it involves like a drug-syndicate or mass murderer. Berk on the other hand, has day-to-day problems that are solved easily but has taken a lot of different routes to drag out the episodes. To give them the benefit of the doubt, it was designed for children whose attention spans are not as long as the adults watching it. There is, however an “extra” that keeps on repeating for Brooklyn Nine-Nine. His name was Doug Judy or more commonly known as the Pontiac bandit. He makes an appearance every season for the past 5 years. He was originally someone that was despised but was later loved by every viewer on the show. The person who I could think of that has similarities with Doug Judy was Alvin the Treacherous. At first everyone hated him, but certain situations happened that made him work with the people on Berk to get him back his island. During the last few episodes, I couldn’t help but empathize with Alvin as he was removed from his island and forced to ask help from his foes. The same thing happens in Brooklyn Nine-Nine as Doug Judy needs help from the Nine-Nine as situations come up to bother him like a serial killer or an adopted brother that wanted him dead. In the end, Alvin was able to fix their broken past with Stoic and they’re now allies, what could one ask for more?
Even if they are similar, they are very different things. I loved everything about Brooklyn Nine-Nine, and I learned to love everything about Riders/Defenders of Berk. The shows have taught me a lot of things especially in dealing with problems that I don’t usually have the ability to deal with, but at the same time they taught me that whatever happens there will always be people there to pick you up when you’re down. You should always be there for them because they will be there for you when you need them also.
I loved one from the start.
I learned to love the other.